Court: Get consent to take pictures of private parts
Fri, Sep 03, 2010
New Straits Times

GEORGE TOWN, MALAYSIA - Surgeons must obtain their female patients' consent before taking pictures of their intimate parts, the High Court ruled yesterday.

Judicial commissioner Chew Soo Ho, in allowing the claim by former reporter Lee Ewe Poh, 51, against general and colorectal surgeon Dr Lim Teik Mau and Loh Guan Lye & Sons Sdn Bhd, said the modesty of female patients must be respected and not violated.

"Failure to do so constitutes invasion of privacy, and a breach of trust and confidence," Chew said in awarding Lee with RM25,000 in general damages and RM10,000 in costs.

Lee had filed the suit against Dr Lim and the hospital, saying that she felt violated after pictures of her private parts were taken during a haemorrhoid surgery.

Chew, in his decision, said the defendants' expert witness Dr Mohamed Akhtar Qureshi, a leading general and colorectal surgeon in the country, had testified that it was an acceptable practice for patients to be photographed under sedation.

However, under cross-examination Dr Akhtar had agreed that the right to make the decision on whether such pictures could be taken or not rested solely on the patients, noting that they must be warned in advance.

"Dr Akhtar said it was only proper to obtain the patients' consent in order for pictures of the intimate parts, particularly female patients be taken.

"Therefore, I find that for a surgeon to take pictures of the intimate parts of female patients, he must first obtain written or verbal consent."

Counsel K. Simon Murali represented Lee, while T. Sagadaven and Ramsun Ho appeared for Dr Lim and the hospital respectively.

Bookmark and Share
  Court: Get consent to take pictures of private parts
  Spy cam suspects identified
  265 dengue outbreak sites declared in Malaysia
  Journalist charged over TNB parody in blog posting
  Woman grossly overcharged by Chinese herbal shop
  Singer who wore sexy outfit for Hungry Ghosts Festival criticised
  Spirit enters medium to ask for forgiveness from family
  Spies caught in act, says aide
  Four siblings surviving on biscuits
  Task force to look out for sensitive matter on Internet
Spy cam suspects identified
Air Supply to tour Malaysia
Malaysian university makes device that cuts pollution
'Cheap fare' offer led to trio's abduction
Probe into leak of text messages, phone calls

Elsewhere in AsiaOne...

Investor Relations: SPH II, Star tie up to provide Malaysia digital media services

Wine,Dine&Unwind: Malaysian-owned Kai restaurant nets Michelin star again

Health: Genetically modified anti-dengue mosquitoes for M'sia?

Motoring: Malaysia's Proton sees first quarter profit jump 55 percent

Digital: Blackmail, the new way

Business: BP sells Malaysian assets to Petronas

Just Women: Smarty Nadine is Miss Universe Malaysia 2010