>> ASIAONE / NEWS / EDUCATION / STORY
Lowering standards not the answer
Sat, Nov 28, 2009
The Straits Times

I FIND it disturbing that many English-speaking families cite Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew's remarks about mistakes in the bilingual policy to justify their inability or that of their children to cope with the Chinese language.

Some even urge de-emphasising Chinese in assessing student performance in examinations.

Related story:
» It's easy to blame teachers or system
» Make mother tongue less critical in PSLE

Many of my friends and I grew up in Mandarin-speaking homes. English was as foreign to us as Chinese was to children from English-speaking families. But we learnt to communicate well in both languages, and we appreciate English literature.

Although it is not easy to be effectively bilingual, it is possible to be comfortable in both languages.

MM Lee is right about sparking interest in learning Chinese, for we learn much better and faster when we are interested in the subject. However, lowering standards will not increase a student's interest in the subject. While teaching Chinese by using English may be useful, the method should be used sparingly during the formative stages of learning the language.

Lowering standards time and again is not the way to pique interest in the language. All Mandarin-speaking students experienced the madness of ting xie (spelling) and mo xie (dictation) during English lessons too because this is a necessary stage when learning a language; there is no short cut.

Many English-speaking parents lament their children's struggle to learn Chinese. They should provide their children with a fun-filled preschool education, not (as was described in a letter) have them examined by a child psychologist to obtain a note to exempt them from the PSLE Chinese exam.

Preschool exposure to Chinese in a fun and stress-free manner will increase their interest in the subject, making it easier to pick up the language.

Tan Ying Hong (Miss)


For more The Straits Times stories, click here.

 
 
STORY INDEX
 
  'Ma, I made it to a US college'
   
 
  Student visa abuse cases on the rise
   
 
  Too much time online hurts your grades: Polls
   
 
  Neighbourhood schools are top of the class
   
 
  Indonesia exams still on despite court ruling
   
 
  Mother tongue is not a substitute for English
   
 
  Chinese-medium schools will promote learning Chinese more effectively
   
 
  Make mother tongue less critical in PSLE
   
 
  Lowering standards not the answer
   
 
  Grain of hope for rice research
   
>> RELATED STORY
Chinese-medium schools will promote learning Chinese more effectively
Make mother tongue less critical in PSLE
Teachers not to blame for language problems
10 years of sheer torture
Nub of problem is motivation and attitude

Elsewhere in AsiaOne...

Wine,Dine&Unwind: Short, shiok Shanghai season

Travel: China's Mongols see bleak future for their culture

Health: China experts identify cancer-preventing gene type

Digital: Chinese don't wait for Apple launch to get iPhone

Just Women: He is inspired by pandas

 

We welcome contributions, comments and tips.
a1admin@sph.com.sg
Search AsiaOne: