>> ASIAONE / NEWS / LATEST NEWS / ASIA / STORY
Aussie judge grants anti-whaling ban against Japan
Tue, Jan 15, 2008
AFP

SYDNEY (Australia) - AUSTRALIA'S Federal Court on Tuesday ordered Japan to stop hunting and killing whales anywhere around its coastline or off Australian Antarctic territory.

The ruling, in a case brought by the Humane Society International, comes with a Japanese fleet sailing in Antarctic waters where they plan to kill around 1,000 whales this season.

Judge James Allsop found that the Japanese company Kyodo Senpaku Kaisha Ltd had killed Antarctic minke and fin whales in Australia's self-declared whale sanctuary, in contravention of Australian law.

The company effectively represents the Japanese whaling industry and runs the ships currently involved in the hunt.

'The court orders that the respondent be restrained from killing, injuring, taking or interfering with any Antarctic minke whale, fin whale or humpback whale in the Australian Whale Sanctuary,' Mr Allsop said.

The Australian Whale Sanctuary generally extends 370 kilometres from the coast, but further in some areas to cover offshore waters and islands, according to the Australian government.

However, the court noted that unless the Japanese whalers entered Australian jurisdiction where they could be seized, there was no practical way the order could be enforced.

Japan exploits a loophole in a 1986 international moratorium on commercial whaling to kill whales for what it calls scientific research, while admitting the meat from the hunt ends up on dinner plates.

Australia has led international opposition to the annual hunt in Antarctic waters, but an expert in international law told AFP the effect of the court?s ruling would be mainly symbolic.

'The Australian Whale Sanctuary is a creature of Australian law,' said Don Rothwell, professor of international law at the Australian National University.

'It's not a zone which is recognised by the international law.'

If the Australian government tried to enforce the court?s order, it would probably spark a major diplomatic row, Mr Rothwell said.

Environment Minister Peter Garrett said he would study the court's decision closely before commenting further.

'The (government) wasn't a party to this case but our intention to continue to have an overall, holistic and fair-dinkum approach to opposing Japanese so-called scientific whaling is absolutely clear,' he told reporters.

Humane Society spokeswoman Nicola Beynon welcomed the court ruling and urged the government to take immediate action against the Japanese whaling fleet.

Although Japan did not recognise Australia's jurisdiction over the whale sanctuary, 'I think it's the Australian government's responsibility to uphold the law and to uphold the Federal Court's injunction,' she told reporters.

A customs vessel dispatched last week by the government to monitor the whalers, the Oceanic Viking, should intercept the fleet and enforce the court order to end the hunt, she told reporters.

'Yes, it would be controversial with the Japanese government but hey, they're the ones who are being extremely provocative in killing whales in Australia's territorial waters and we think it's time that this whole matter is brought to a head.'

The government has said the Oceanic Viking's mission is to gather video and other evidence of Japanese whaling for use in possible legal action against Tokyo.

Mr Rothwell said this was probably a better option and could be done through the International Court of Justice in The Hague or the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea in Hamburg.

Meanwhile, environmental groups Greenpeace and Sea Shepherd said this week their ships had located the Japanese whalers in Antarctic waters and had 'chased' them from the hunting zone. -- AFP

 

 
STORY INDEX
 
  Aussie judge grants anti-whaling ban against Japan
   
 
  Ancient dinosaur fossil haul returned to China
   
 
  Key Thai election ruling due on Friday
   
 
  UN tribunal meets Khmer Rouge cadres to calm fears
   
 
  Citroen apologises to China for scowling Mao ad
   
 
  Top Chinese official given death sentence for graft
   
 
  Freighter sinks off Taiwan, killing eight
   
 
  China to plant 2.5 billion trees
   
 
  Indonesia's Suharto still improving
   
 
  At least 20 hurt in blast in southern Thailand
   
We welcome contributions, comments and tips.
a1admin@sph.com.sg
Search: